|
Evaluation of cases submitted
As in any refereed journal, cases submitted for
publication in the International Journal of Case Studies in Management are subject to peer review. Cases are evaluated mainly on the basis of
the editorial policy established by the Journal. To find out more
about the criteria on which this process is based, contributors can consult
the evaluation form and the Evaluation Guidelines for Teaching Notes used by
evaluators. To the extent that it allows Review Committee members and
evaluators to ensure the quality of the cases published, this activity
represents an essential component of the Journal’s mission.
To ensure the effectiveness of the review process,
several professors have been placed in charge of the evaluation mechanism in
their respective fields of interest. Their task
consists in considering the cases received by the Centre in order to
determine their suitability for evaluation by peers and in choosing the
professors to whom the cases will be submitted for evaluation.
The final issue of each year contains a list of all the individuals who
served as evaluators during the year.
Review Committee
List of professors responsible for the evaluation
mechanism in their respective sectors:
-
Carmen Bernier, Associate Professor. Faculty of
Administrative Sciences, Université Laval
-
Lucie Morissette, Associate Professor. Human Resources Management, HEC Montréal
-
Johanne Brunet, Associate Professor. Department of Marketing, HEC Montréal
-
Silvia I. Ponce, Associate Professor. Logistics and Operations Management, HEC Montréal
-
Taiëb Hafsi, Professor. Business Strategy, HEC Montréal
-
Veronika Kisfalvi, Professor. Management, HEC Montréal
-
Jacques Fortin, Professor. Accounting and Accounting Science, HEC Montréal
-
François Leroux, Professor. Economy and Industry, HEC Montréal
-
Alix Mandron, Professor. Finance, HEC Montréal
Editorial Board
The mandate of the Editorial Board is to define the
main orientations of the Journal and to ensure respect for its
editorial policy. It is also responsible for overseeing matters relating to
the Journal’s operations and the selection of cases for publication.
The Editorial Board is also occasionally called upon to solve problems
arising concerning operations and publication of the cases retained.
The Board is made up of the following members:
Anne Mesny, Associate Professor, Department of Management, HEC Montréal; Editor-in-Chief of the International Journal of Case Studies in Management
Emmanuel B. Raufflet, Associate Professor, Department of Management, HEC Montréal;
Anne Chartier, Associate Professor, Management Information Systems Department, Faculty of
Administrative Sciences, Université Laval;
Carmen Bernier, Associate Professor, Faculty of
Administrative Sciences, Université Laval.
Evaluation guide and form for cases submitted for
publication
The evaluators selected by the members of the Review
Committee base their assessment of the cases and teaching notes they receive
on several criteria. Authors interested in finding out more about the
Journal’s standards can consult the evaluation form and guidelines that
are provided to evaluators along with the case studies and teaching notes to
be evaluated.
-
Case Evaluation Form
-
Evaluation Guidelines for Teaching Notes (evaluator’s
version)
-
Style Guide for Cases and Teaching Notes
-
Guides to teaching notes
|
